Go ahead, take the EP's and make your dream set list. It'll be fun. Also valid are unreleased Clementines tracks, and I'll say up to 3 Charm School tracks if you so desire. Go for it.

Me, in chronological order (though I'll see about re-ordering it later):

Making Friends (January)
The Bullet and Big D (January)
Vain (February)
Queen of the Rummage Sale (February)
The History of Excuses (March)
The Monitor (March) - I only wanted this AFTER hearing August... good stuff
A Tiny Fold (May)
That Summer (May)
Light of the Lost (June)
Black Suburbans (June) - way underappreciated! Awesome song!
Click Click Click Click (July) - rocking, if possible
Walk on By (July)
People You Meet (July)
Last Chance America
The Flood
Down to Memphis

Obviously this is a way-long set, but hey... BA should be playing sets this epic!