ian wrote:i feel bad about criticizing them here, but i think this quite far the worst (least best!) ep so far. 'the same fire' is pretty nice, but would be about 3rd best track on all the other eps at the most, and the others dont seem to do much for me. oh well, maybe it will grow. why's it so down anyway? its summer, it should be happy and poppy and fun!
Ian, shame on you for downloading after all those patient months waiting for your extra Christmases. (metaphor originally stated by ian)
badnun99 wrote:The lyrics for "Fire" are completely phoned in. I'm a little dissapointed. However, I feel the music is still quite strong.
Umm... I disconcur?
DrewMG wrote:My least favorite EP so far is May (with the exception of Butterfly Nets).
Shame on you! May's my favorite in two or three months.
DrewMG wrote:I think July needs a few more rockin' tunes.
Though I haven't heard June yet, I'm going to have to agree. Lately it's been Bishop Allen tries new direction (note that's a singular noun): slow and deep. Deep's good, but NATTY LOVE CATCHY. Instant catches win me over a lot better than long periods of study of the same track.
that bubba guy wrote:I think this one needs to grow on me, but this one should have been the start of like three EPs of kick ass fun pop rock. Instead, they're all slow and quiet. Maybe July will spark things up a bit.
Yeah, agreed. I like Bishop Allen's experiments, but I miss what I fell in love with about BA.
EDIT: Emily, is bbcode off?
